Episode 412, "Knuckle Up" Today 12|11c
SEASON 1, EPISODE 113 - Rush confronts her oldest murder case yet when Sarah Tucker (Leslie Silva), the 40-year-old granddaughter of Sadie Douglas (Meta Golding), a black woman who was murdered in 1939, provides letters Sadie wrote to Sarah's mother, at one point seeming to implicate a milkman. Among the fragile, yellowing case files from the period, Rush finds a train ticket dated the night of the killing and begins to track down Sadie's surviving friends. She also learns that two milkmen who delivered to the boarding house where Sadie lived belonged to a white supremacist group and had threatened her. But when Rush finally finds one of the milkmen, now a feeble 90-year-old living in Queens, New York, she discovers the truth of what happened that night six decades ago is much more shocking than anyone imagined.