Episode 412, "Knuckle Up" Friday, May 24, 12|11c
SEASON 3, EPISODE 301 - When Claire (Brooke anne smith), a 17-year-old foster child, tells Rush that a man claiming to be her father contacted her, the team reopens the murder of Jimmy Tate (Chuck Hittinger), a teenager who was run over by a car on the night Claire was born. Rush and Valens question Claire's mother, Quinn Ellis (Nathalie Nicole Paulding, 1988; Amy van horne, present), Jimmy's former girlfriend, who gave birth the night she and Jimmy graduated from high school. Quinn dearly loved Jimmy--who she claims was the baby's father--but he terminated their relationship before the baby was born. However, the investigators quickly discover that Quinn's claims may not be true.